[HM] Zwbigniew Moron'

Samuel S. Kutler (s-kutler@sjca.edu)
Mon, 21 Sep 1998 16:21:22 -0400 (EDT)

Friends:

I now have a copy of the 1925 article by Moron'

ON THE DIVISION OF RECTANGLES INTO SQUARES,

which was published in Poland in Polish, but I also have a translation into
English by a colleague of mine here at St. John's in Annapolis.

Moron' found two squared rectangles--all squares unequal--of order ten and
nine. It is clear that he did not know of the OTHER squared rectangle of
order nine.

He refers to a theorem by M. Dehn in Math. Annalen in 1903, which shows
that a necessary condition for tiling a rectangle with squares is that the
sides of the squares be commensurable. If I remember correctly, Sherman K.
Stein proves this theorem in

MATHEMATICS THE MAN-MADE UNIVERSE

in his chapter on tiling. I wonder whether or not Stein knew this theorem
from Max Dehn or from elsewhere.

Z. M. doesn't even know whether or not there might be a smaller squared
rectangle than order nine, and he also remarks

we don't know whether a square can be divided into unequal squares.

One should publish a nice pamphlet consisting of

Dehn's Theorem

The article by Moron'

The Sprague article--perhaps 1939--that gives the first squared-square.
It is imperfect, for it contains a sub-rectangle made up of squares.

The article (1940?) by four Englishmen, which has the first perfect
squared-square, and, I think, the proof by Tutte that there is no
cubed-cube (all cubes unequal).

The article(s) by A J W Duijvestijn that not only gives the smallest
squared-square, of order 21, but also proves that there is nothing.
smaller.

Best wishes,

Sam Kutler